Is WholeHearted dog food worth buying? For most budget-conscious owners, yes. WholeHearted is Petco's exclusive, mid-priced brand that leads its recipes with real meat, has never been recalled, and is formulated with Petco's veterinarians and nutritionists. It's a solid value pick — with a few caveats around pea-and-lentil-heavy grain-free formulas and meat meals worth understanding before you switch.
What Is WholeHearted Dog Food?
WholeHearted is a private-label pet food line launched by Petco in 2016 and sold almost exclusively through Petco stores and petco.com (with limited availability on Amazon, Walmart, and a few other retailers). According to A-Z Animals, Petco created the brand to give shoppers a "wholesome nutritional choice at a reasonable price," positioning it below premium names like Blue Buffalo while aiming for comparable quality.
The lineup is broad: dry kibble, canned and pouch wet food, treats, meal toppers, and fresh-food options, with recipes for every life stage and specialty formulas targeting sensitive stomachs, urinary support, and allergies. Because it's a store brand, WholeHearted skips the marketing markup of national brands — which is a big part of why it lands cheaper on the shelf.
WholeHearted Ingredients: What's Actually Inside
The good news first: real meat — chicken, beef, salmon, lamb, or duck — is consistently the first ingredient across WholeHearted recipes. The Dogster review found mostly natural ingredients with minimal fillers, plus useful additions like probiotics and vitamin supplements. Recipes exclude artificial colors and dyes.
There are two things to look at more closely. First, several grain-free formulas rely heavily on peas and lentils, which Dogster notes "skirt very closely to contradicting the grain-free promise" — legumes stand in for grains as a cheaper protein and carbohydrate source. Second, WagWalking points out that while whole meat leads the label, it's often followed by meat by-products and meat meals rather than additional whole-meat sources. Meat meals aren't inherently bad — they're concentrated protein — but they're a lower-cost ingredient than fresh muscle meat.
It's also worth remembering, as the World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) stresses, that an ingredient list alone "gives no information on the quality of the ingredients and can be very misleading." A tidy first ingredient doesn't guarantee a great diet — the manufacturing, testing, and nutritional formulation behind it matter more.
WholeHearted Product Lines and Price
WholeHearted sits in the affordable-to-mid tier. WagWalking reports some dry formulas run under $1.50 per pound and wet pouches around $1.40 each — genuinely appealing for multi-dog households or large breeds that eat a lot. Buying directly from Petco is typically cheaper than third-party sellers.
Key collections include:
- Grain-Free recipes built around meat plus peas, lentils, and potatoes.
- Grain-Inclusive options with brown rice, oatmeal, or barley for owners who prefer grains.
- Sensitive Stomach & Skin limited-ingredient formulas.
- Active Performance higher-protein recipes for working and high-energy dogs.
- Puppy and Senior life-stage diets.
If your dog has a tender gut, it's worth comparing these against the criteria in our guide to choosing food for sensitive stomachs before committing.
Is WholeHearted Grain-Free Food Safe?
This is the most common worry, and it deserves a careful, honest answer. Since 2018, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration has investigated a possible connection between grain-free diets high in peas, lentils, and potatoes and cases of canine dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM), a serious heart condition. Of the DCM reports the FDA reviewed, 91% involved grain-free diets and 93% contained peas and/or lentils.
Crucially, the FDA has not established that grain-free food causes DCM. As of its most recent update, the agency calls the relationship "a complex scientific issue that may involve multiple factors," and its testing found no abnormalities in taurine, amino acids, or minerals in grain-free foods compared to grain-inclusive ones. The investigation remains open but inconclusive.
What does that mean for WholeHearted? Its grain-free recipes are pea- and lentil-forward, so they fall into the general category the FDA has been watching. That's not a verdict against the food — millions of dogs eat legume-based diets without issue — but if your dog is a breed predisposed to heart disease, or you simply want to sidestep the question, WholeHearted's grain-inclusive lines are an easy alternative. Diet is a health decision: talk to your veterinarian before switching foods or choosing between grain-free and grain-inclusive, especially for a dog with existing health conditions.
Recall History and Manufacturing
WholeHearted's track record here is genuinely strong: the brand has never been recalled as of this writing, which every major review (Dogster, A-Z Animals, WagWalking) highlights as impressive for a line that launched in 2016. Recipes are formulated with input from Petco's veterinarians and nutritionists.
One nuance: while much WholeHearted food is made in the United States, WagWalking notes that some wet recipes are produced in Thailand, and ingredients are sourced internationally before U.S. manufacturing. That's common across the industry and not a red flag on its own, but it's worth knowing if country-of-origin matters to you.
WholeHearted Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Real meat as the first ingredient in every recipe
- No recalls to date
- Affordable, especially for multi-dog and large-breed homes
- Formulated with Petco veterinarians and nutritionists
- Wide range of formats, proteins, and specialty formulas
- No artificial colors or dyes; includes probiotics
Cons:
- Grain-free formulas are heavy on peas and lentils
- Meat by-products and meals often follow the lead protein
- Sold almost exclusively through Petco
- Some wet food made overseas
- Protein levels trail premium competitors outside the Performance line
Who Should (and Shouldn't) Feed WholeHearted
A good fit for: budget-minded owners who want a step up from bargain-bin kibble, multi-dog households, and Petco regulars who value convenience and the brand's clean recall record.
Maybe look elsewhere if: your dog needs a therapeutic prescription diet, you want the highest possible whole-meat protein content, you prefer to avoid legume-heavy grain-free recipes, or you don't have easy access to Petco. For puppies of larger breeds, cross-check against our roundup of large-breed puppy foods to make sure the calcium and calorie balance fits.
How to Evaluate Any Dog Food
WholeHearted aside, the smartest habit is knowing how to judge a food yourself. The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) sets the model standards U.S. states adopt, and a food's AAFCO nutritional adequacy statement tells you whether it's "complete and balanced" for your dog's life stage. WSAVA recommends looking past the ingredient list to questions like: Does the company employ a qualified nutritionist? Where and how is the food made and tested? Can they provide a full nutrient analysis? Those answers reveal far more than a marketing-friendly first ingredient. A spoonful of fermented foods or the occasional topper can round out a solid base diet, too.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is WholeHearted a good dog food?
For its price point, yes. WholeHearted offers real-meat-first recipes, a clean recall history, and vet-and-nutritionist formulation at a mid-range cost. It's not a premium ultra-high-protein food, but it's a reliable everyday option for many dogs.
Who makes WholeHearted dog food?
WholeHearted is Petco's own private-label brand, launched in 2016 and sold primarily through Petco stores and petco.com. Recipes are developed with Petco's veterinarians and nutritionists.
Has WholeHearted dog food ever been recalled?
No. As of this writing, WholeHearted has never had a recall, which is a strong safety indicator for a brand of its age.
Is WholeHearted grain-free food safe?
The FDA has investigated a possible link between legume-heavy grain-free diets and canine DCM but has not proven that grain-free food causes it. WholeHearted's grain-free recipes are pea- and lentil-based, so if you're concerned, its grain-inclusive lines are a simple alternative. Ask your vet for guidance.
Is WholeHearted as good as Blue Buffalo?
Reviewers rate WholeHearted as comparable in quality to Blue Buffalo at a lower price, though premium lines from some competitors carry higher whole-meat protein content. The best choice depends on your dog's needs and your budget.
How much does WholeHearted dog food cost?
It's affordable for its tier — some dry formulas run under $1.50 per pound and wet pouches around $1.40 each, with the best pricing when you buy directly from Petco.
This review is for general informational purposes and isn't a substitute for veterinary advice. Your dog's ideal diet depends on their age, weight, and health — consult your veterinarian before making a switch.
Want more honest dog-food breakdowns and buying guides? Subscribe to the Daily Wag newsletter for straight-talking reviews, nutrition tips, and dog-care answers delivered every week.
